Imagine standing at the base of Mount Rushmore, the iconic faces of American presidents gazing down upon you. The majesty is breathtaking. But all that sightseeing works up an appetite! Planning a trip to see this incredible monument, and other attractions in the Black Hills? Don’t let subpar meals ruin your experience. Keystone, South Dakota, a charming town nestled at the foot of the mountains, offers a surprisingly diverse culinary scene, one that goes far beyond tourist traps.
This guide will help you discover the best restaurants, cafes, and eateries in Keystone, ensuring you have a delicious and memorable visit. Whether you’re craving a hearty steak, a comforting pizza, or a quick bite to fuel your adventures, Keystone has something to satisfy every palate. We’ll explore everything from classic American fare to unexpected international delights, uncovering the best spots that both locals and tourists rave about.
Keystone’s Culinary Landscape: A Quick Overview
Keystone’s dining scene is, in many ways, defined by its location. As a gateway to Mount Rushmore and other major Black Hills attractions, tourism is a major driving force. You’ll find a good mix of casual, family-friendly restaurants, alongside a few more upscale establishments. The atmosphere, for the most part, is relaxed and welcoming, reflecting the laid-back vibe of the town itself.
While you won’t necessarily find cutting-edge culinary trends here, you will discover a focus on satisfying, comforting food. Expect to see plenty of hearty American dishes, with influences from the Midwest. Bison, a regional specialty, often makes an appearance on menus, as does trout, a delicious freshwater fish found in local streams. Depending on the season, you might also encounter dishes featuring local berries or other seasonal ingredients.
Price ranges vary, of course, but generally, you can expect to find options to suit most budgets. From budget-friendly cafes offering sandwiches and soups to more refined steakhouses, Keystone caters to a wide range of travelers and local residents. Expect to spend anywhere from fifteen dollars per person for a quick lunch to fifty dollars or more for a multi-course dinner at a nicer restaurant.
Top Restaurant Recommendations
Let’s dive into the heart of this guide: our recommendations for the best places to eat in Keystone. We’ve broken them down by cuisine or dining style to make it easier for you to find what you’re looking for.
Best American and Steakhouses
For a truly satisfying meal, look no further than the steakhouses in Keystone. These establishments specialize in perfectly grilled meats and classic American sides.
Consider The Ruby House Restaurant. Located in a historic building with a charming atmosphere, The Ruby House is known for its excellent steaks, prime rib, and seafood. Their signature dish, the “Ruby’s Ribeye,” is a must-try, perfectly seasoned and cooked to your exact specifications. The restaurant offers a wide selection of wines and cocktails to complement your meal. Expect to pay around thirty to sixty dollars per person for dinner. The Ruby House is a favorite for its consistent quality and welcoming ambiance, making it a great choice for a special occasion or a memorable family meal.
Then there’s Powder House Lodge. This restaurant offers a beautiful setting within a rustic lodge. It boasts a menu of American classics with a focus on local ingredients. While they have delicious steaks, the Powder House Lodge also serves great pasta, chicken, and fish, all prepared in generous portions and well-seasoned. They have a great kids’ menu and a casual atmosphere making this a good option if you have children. Budget roughly twenty to forty dollars per person. It stands out for its cozy atmosphere and commitment to providing high-quality food at reasonable prices.
Best Casual Dining and Family Friendly
Traveling with kids? Or simply looking for a relaxed and informal dining experience? Keystone has plenty of great options for casual dining.
Check out Grapes and Grinds. While technically a coffee shop and wine bar, Grapes and Grinds also offers a tasty menu of sandwiches, salads, and light bites. It’s a perfect spot for a quick lunch or a relaxing afternoon snack. Their paninis are particularly popular, and their coffee is consistently excellent. Expect to spend around ten to twenty dollars per person. Grapes and Grinds is cherished for its friendly service and laid-back vibe, providing a welcoming space for locals and tourists alike.
For a classic American burger, stop by The Red Garter Saloon. With a fun, Old West themed decor, The Red Garter offers juicy burgers with a number of different toppings. They also have a full bar, and often have live music making it a great option for a fun night out. The burgers will cost you around fifteen dollars each. The Red Garter stands out for its lively environment and high-quality ingredients.
Best Pizza and Italian
When you’re craving pizza or pasta, these Keystone establishments deliver.
You can’t go wrong with Maria’s Greek and Italian Cuisine. They serve classic pasta dishes like spaghetti carbonara and lasagna, plus delicious pizzas with a wide variety of toppings, and tasty salads. The pizzas are cooked to perfection in a brick oven, and the pasta is always fresh and flavorful. Expect to pay around fifteen to thirty dollars per person. Maria’s is loved for its generous portions, authentic flavors, and friendly service, providing a taste of Italy in the heart of the Black Hills.
Best Breakfast and Brunch
Start your day off right with a delicious breakfast or brunch at one of Keystone’s best spots.
Consider stopping by The Keystone Coffee Shop. A local favorite, The Keystone Coffee Shop serves classic breakfast fare, including pancakes, waffles, omelets, and breakfast sandwiches. They also have a wide selection of coffee and tea. This place is great for a quick meal before exploring all that the Black Hills has to offer. Expect to spend around ten to fifteen dollars per person.
Best Quick Bites and Snacks
Need a quick treat or a refreshing beverage? These spots have you covered.
Don’t miss Mount Rushmore Candy Company. This delightful shop offers a wide variety of candies, chocolates, and ice cream. It’s the perfect place to satisfy your sweet tooth. It’s great for an afternoon treat, and a good place to pick up a souvenir as well!
Best for Views and Ambiance
If you’re looking for a restaurant with stunning views and a memorable atmosphere, look no further.
Skogen Kitchen combines great food with unforgettable vistas. Perched on a hillside overlooking the Black Hills, this restaurant offers panoramic views that are simply breathtaking. The menu features modern American cuisine with a focus on fresh, seasonal ingredients. Expect to pay a bit more for the experience, around forty to seventy dollars per person. Skogen Kitchen stands out for its impeccable service, elegant ambiance, and of course, those incredible views. It’s a perfect choice for a romantic dinner or a special celebration.
Beyond the Main Restaurants: Hidden Gems and Local Favorites
While the restaurants listed above are well-known and popular, Keystone also has a few hidden gems worth discovering.
Consider The Holy Terror Saloon. While it’s primarily a bar, The Holy Terror Saloon also serves a small but tasty menu of pub fare, including burgers, sandwiches, and appetizers. What makes this place special is its atmosphere. The Holy Terror Saloon is located in a historic building with a rich and colorful past. The walls are adorned with antique artifacts and vintage photographs, creating a truly unique and immersive experience. The saloon is known for its friendly bartenders and lively atmosphere, making it a great place to unwind after a long day of sightseeing. Be sure to check it out.
Tips for Dining in Keystone
To make the most of your dining experience in Keystone, keep these tips in mind:
Reservations are highly recommended, especially during peak season (summer months). Many of the popular restaurants can get very busy, so booking in advance will ensure you get a table.
Restaurant hours may vary, especially outside of the main tourist season. Some restaurants may close early or be closed entirely during the off-season. It’s always a good idea to check online or call ahead to confirm their hours of operation.
Most Keystone restaurants are accommodating to dietary restrictions, such as vegetarian, gluten-free, or vegan options. However, it’s always best to inform your server of any dietary needs when you order.
Parking can be challenging in Keystone, especially during peak season. Some restaurants have their own parking lots, while others rely on street parking. Be sure to allow extra time to find parking, and be prepared to walk a bit.
Keep an eye out for local events and festivals, which often feature special food offerings. Keystone hosts several events throughout the year, including the Keystone Wine & Art Festival, the Black Hills Bluegrass Festival, and the Mount Rushmore Lighting Ceremony.
In Conclusion
Keystone, South Dakota, is more than just a gateway to Mount Rushmore; it’s a destination with a surprisingly vibrant culinary scene. From hearty steakhouses and cozy cafes to family-friendly restaurants and hidden gems, Keystone offers a variety of dining options to suit every taste and budget. So, next time you’re visiting Mount Rushmore, take some time to explore the delicious side of Keystone. You might just discover your new favorite restaurant. Don’t be afraid to venture beyond the main attractions and try something new. The best culinary experiences are often found in the most unexpected places. Bon appétit!
Share your favorite Keystone restaurants in the comments below! We’d love to hear about your experiences and recommendations. And be sure to check out our other articles on travel in South Dakota for more inspiration and ideas for your next adventure.
