St. Augustine, Florida, the nation’s oldest city, is a destination steeped in history and brimming with coastal charm. While its historical landmarks and stunning architecture often take center stage, a lesser-known treasure awaits discovery: its vibrant and diverse food scene. From freshly caught seafood to Spanish-influenced delicacies, and comforting local favorites to delectable sweet treats, St. Augustine offers a culinary journey that will tantalize your taste buds and leave you craving more. Get ready to explore the best of St. Augustine’s culinary landscape, where good food is an integral part of the city’s unique character.
Fresh Seafood Delights
Being a coastal city, St. Augustine boasts an abundance of fresh seafood, a cornerstone of its culinary identity. Restaurants across the city capitalize on the daily catch, offering a variety of dishes that showcase the ocean’s bounty.
One establishment that truly stands out is The Reef. Perched overlooking the Atlantic Ocean, The Reef delivers not only exquisite seafood but also breathtaking views. Their menu features a variety of seafood dishes, but their shrimp and grits are arguably the best in town. Prepared with locally sourced shrimp, creamy grits, and a savory sauce, this classic Southern dish is elevated to new heights. The ambiance is sophisticated yet relaxed, making it perfect for a romantic dinner or a special occasion.
For a more casual seafood experience, head to Aunt Kate’s. Nestled along the Tolomato River, Aunt Kate’s specializes in Minorcan cuisine, a unique blend of Spanish, Mediterranean, and Floridian flavors. Their steamed clams are a must-try, cooked in a flavorful broth with herbs and spices. The outdoor seating area, with its views of the water and live music, creates a relaxed and enjoyable atmosphere. Aunt Kate’s offers a taste of old Florida charm and delicious, authentic Minorcan seafood.
Another notable mention is O’Steens Restaurant. A St. Augustine institution, O’Steens has been serving up fresh, local seafood for decades. Their fried shrimp is legendary, perfectly crispy and bursting with flavor. With its unpretentious atmosphere and consistently delicious food, O’Steens is a beloved local spot for a reason. Be prepared for a wait, especially during peak season, but the food is well worth it.
Spanish and Mediterranean Influences
St. Augustine’s rich history as a Spanish colony has left an indelible mark on its culinary scene. Spanish and Mediterranean flavors are woven throughout the city’s restaurants, offering a taste of the Old World with a Floridian twist.
Columbia Restaurant, a St. Augustine landmark, is the oldest restaurant in Florida and a testament to the city’s Spanish heritage. With its ornate decor, lively atmosphere, and authentic Cuban cuisine, Columbia is an experience in itself. Their signature dish, the “Original” Cuban Sandwich, is a must-try. Another popular menu item is the Paella a la Valenciana, a traditional Spanish rice dish with seafood, chicken, and vegetables. With its rich history and delicious food, Columbia Restaurant is a culinary institution that should not be missed.
For a more modern take on Mediterranean cuisine, check out Michael’s Tasting Room. Chef Michael Lugo brings his culinary expertise to this elegant restaurant, creating innovative and flavorful dishes using fresh, local ingredients. Their menu features a variety of Mediterranean-inspired dishes, with an emphasis on seafood and vegetables. The ambiance is sophisticated and intimate, making it perfect for a romantic dinner or a special occasion.
Another place offering great eats is The Spanish Bakery and Cafe. Step back in time at this humble cafe, a St. Augustine staple, for traditional Spanish treats. Empanadas, Cuban sandwiches, and a range of sweet and savory delights fill the menu, all at reasonable prices. It’s the perfect spot for a quick bite that highlights the city’s cultural heritage.
Casual Eats and Local Favorites
Sometimes, the best food is found in the most unassuming places. St. Augustine is home to a variety of casual eateries and local favorites that offer delicious food without the fuss.
For a classic burger experience, look no further than Burrito Works Taco Shop. While the name might suggest otherwise, Burrito Works makes a truly exceptional burger. Made with high-quality beef and fresh toppings, their burgers are cooked to perfection. The atmosphere is casual and laid-back, making it a great spot for a quick and satisfying meal. And yes, the burritos are also pretty good.
If you’re craving a good sandwich, visit The Kookaburra Coffee. While they are primarily known for their coffee, their sandwiches are not to be missed. Made with fresh ingredients and creative flavor combinations, their sandwiches are a cut above the rest. The atmosphere is cozy and inviting, making it a great place to relax and enjoy a delicious sandwich.
For a taste of authentic Florida cuisine, head to Creekside Dinery. Located on the water, this spot is known for it’s fried seafood baskets and tasty burgers. This is a spot where the locals like to come and relax.
Sweet Treats and Coffee
No culinary journey is complete without indulging in some sweet treats and a good cup of coffee. St. Augustine has a variety of options to satisfy your sweet tooth and caffeine cravings.
For the ice cream lovers, visit Mayday Handcrafted Ice Creams. With its unique flavors and handcrafted approach, Mayday is a must-visit for ice cream enthusiasts. Their ice cream is made with fresh, local ingredients, and their flavors range from classic to creative. The atmosphere is fun and whimsical, making it a great spot for families.
When you need that afternoon jolt, head to The Kookaburra Coffee. With a variety of coffee drinks and comfortable seating, this spot will get you on your way.
For a great cake or pastry, try Creme de la Cocoa. This is the place for great sweets and treats.
Fine Dining Experiences
For those seeking a more refined culinary experience, St. Augustine offers a selection of fine dining restaurants that deliver exceptional food and service.
Collage Restaurant stands out as one of St. Augustine’s premier fine dining establishments. With its elegant atmosphere, impeccable service, and creative cuisine, Collage is perfect for a special occasion. Their menu features a variety of dishes with a focus on fresh seafood and locally sourced ingredients.
Another solid option is Catch 27. Catch 27 offers a relaxed atmosphere that pairs with high end seafood and plates.
Conclusion
St. Augustine’s culinary scene is a reflection of its rich history and diverse culture. From fresh seafood and Spanish-influenced dishes to casual eats and delectable desserts, the city offers a culinary experience for every palate. Whether you’re a foodie seeking the latest culinary trends or simply looking for a delicious meal, St. Augustine has something to offer. Explore the restaurants mentioned in this guide, discover your own favorite spots, and let the flavors of St. Augustine tantalize your taste buds. Good food is an integral part of experiencing the charm and character of this ancient city, so come hungry and prepare to be amazed. Let this city’s incredible eats be part of your adventure!
